Pros and cons for each will be given and a winner will be chosen. The character has the same name in both the book and the movie. Using graphic organizers, they can compare and contrast the book and the movie. A lot of what happens in the movie and the book are the same. Whether or not the movie will have the same impact on someone who hasnt read the novel is. Sahara feels more like a 1940s serial than a book written in 1991 or a movie made in 2005. Something that i have never said when comparing a novel to a film, is that the pacing and. That said, id recommend seeing the movie as well but maybe read the book first if you can. Author asher has written an excellent book on an expedition by the french in 1880 to cross the. In the movie this was invented for the movie and does not happen at all in the book. How do you write a paper on comparing a movie with the book.
Ways that the book and movie are different include. A lot of people would rather watch a movie than read a book, claiming that it is not worth spending effort and time as you can watch the movie without requiring much effort from your side. Its one of the most successful intellectual properties of our time, generating a massive revenue stream and commanding extraordinary brand name recognition globally. Casting choices for the movie felt strange to me i pictured dirk pitt with more of a. A week before the surrender of confederate forces of robert e. Ive been saying for years that this series needed to be made into a series of movies, one for nearly every book.
Starting with the post you are reading right now, i be conducting book vs. Clive cussler really, really dislikes sahara john august. Jun 30, 2009 its a great read, and the tone of the novel reads very realistically, because though it is based upon extremes, what happens in the book could actually happen in real life. Then when it finally happens you barely recognize it on the big screen. Good ones for this are the harry potter series, holes, the chronicles of narnia series, and where. Master explorer dirk pitt goes on the adventure of a lifetime of seeking out a lost civil war battleship known as the ship of death in the deserts of west africa while helping a who doctor being hounded by a ruthless dictator.
That said, id recommend seeing the movie as well but. It was also a great basis for the movie sahara, starring matthew mcconaughey, penelope cruz, and steve zahn. Both essential to the people who live in and around them, these deserts are far more than just barren land. The movie never brought up mitchs brother like they did in the book. Then i watched the movie version of the same story. Even with my appreciation for the movie the effects, the way it was shot, and, of course, the actors who were amazing, by the way it still didnt cut it for me. Aug 30, 2017 lots of amazing books have been turned into movies, and lots of great movies started life as books, so now its time to decide, which is better for these stories, the books or the movies. Nov 19, 2015 books vs movies moreover, there is a consensus that the book is better than the movie. Have you ever waited for your favorite book to be turned into a movie. Filling nearly all of northern africa, it measures approximately 3,000 miles 4,800 km from east to west and between 800 to 1,200 miles from north to south and has a total area of some 3,320,000 square miles 8,600,000 square km.
First blood is best known as the first rambo movie. And we can see why its a book by stephen king, a film by stanley kubrick, and the. What are the differences between the baseball movie the. Finally, they select a scene from the book that they think wasnt well represented in the movie and adapt it for a readers theater performance.
A worldfamous australian aviatrix, kitty mannock, vanishes mysteriously in the middle of the sahara while attempting a recordbreaking flight from london to capetown and is never see again it is 1995. Whats the difference comes at you this week with one of the most popular viewer suggestions. A lot of parents want their kids to read the book then watch the movie. A grid which allows children to compare the characters and setting of a book and film version as well as give their opinion of the different versions. I wasnt sure which subreddit to put this on, but im hoping someone here can help me. In this comparison article, we take a look at the key characteristics of both great deserts. What are the differences between the baseball movie. But before all that, first blood was a novel by david morrell. Sahara author clive cussler clive cussler adventure book. They did such a stellar job with casting that the book was just plain sad in comparison. It is the eleventh book in cusslers dirk pitt series. Lots of amazing books have been turned into movies, and lots of great movies started life as books, so now its time to decide, which is better for these stories, the books or the movies. I really enjoy these times because they read the book to read and enjoy the book, and not just to get to the movie.
The novel and the film are not siblings or even distant cousins. Describe one way the movie and the book were the same. Sahara clive cusslers novel sahara astounded me with its intense plot, diverse characters, and intriguing settings. I believe changes were made to make things more interesting. In this lesson we compare a book to its film version and discuss several things to. But, the movie does depart slightly from the book in order to create a great action story that can be neatly put into a 2. Same characters different plot events phillip was blind. So the little prince is a timeless childrens book thats been pretty popular since its publication in the 1940s.
Whenever your essay topic involves comparison, you can organize in either of two ways. For example, jo spends time with laurie at a dance and mr. The world is home to many deserts but few are more impressive and more important than the sahara desert and the arabian desert. The book focuses on an aviator who is talking directly to the readers and telling them of the time he met the little prince and what he learned from the princes story. A worldfamous australian aviatrix, kitty mannock, vanishes mysteriously in the middle of the sahara while attempting a recordbreaking flight from london to capetown and is. As much a mini war movie as it is an action flick, sahara features lots of fistfights, shootouts, massive explosions and neardeath experiences. The movie also lost a bit of that tongueincheek comedy with the action scenes the. In bernard malamuds the natural, roy hobbs ends in ignominious defeat. And after doing this, the book makes chris seem like some insensitive jerk that has no feelings at all. Clive cussler, who wrote the novel that inspired sahara, is said to have rejected untold drafts of the screenplay and sued paramount over this. Featured comparison the sum of all fears 87 differences. A movie and novel comparison megan bright 9 nov 2011 beastly slideshare uses cookies to improve functionality and performance, and to provide you with relevant advertising. Sahara is a 2005 actionadventure comedy film directed by breck eisner that is based on the bestselling book of the same name by clive cussler. A smart novelist remembers that the existence of a movie doesnt change anything about the book sold at barnes and noble.
Differences between the amityville horror book vs movie page 1. The extra context makes the story more compelling and the emotional side of the story is portrayed with words in a way thats difficult on a screen. While some people prefer to read the book first and others want to see the movie before reading the book, there is value in comparing books and movies. First, you can write about each thing separately and then include a section in which you make comparisons and contrasts between them. Designed for phase 6 of unit 3 of the literacy framework for year 1. As amazing as the movie sahara is, the book its based on threw it out of the water. When i finally heard that in fact a movie, based on the book sahara, was finally in production. A lot of people would rather watch a movie than read a book, claiming that it is not worth spending effort and time as you can watch. Comparing a book and film version of a story teaching. Clive cussler had wide discretion over the script for his novel sahara. Clive cussler extraordinary creative control over sahara, the movie. May 20, 2015 whats the difference comes at you this week with one of the most popular viewer suggestions.
If you read the book, you have an image in your head of what the character looks like, what their voices sound like. He strikes out, throws the series, is left broke, unloved, an outcast. Mar 17, 2010 a grid which allows children to compare the characters and setting of a book and film version as well as give their opinion of the different versions. Feb, 2015 overall, if im pitting the book versus the movie, id choose the book. Same plot events different characters both got stuck on a island. A few bangs for your buck in this moderate family actionadventure, adapted from a clive cussler novel. The movie also lost a bit of that tongueincheek comedy with the action scenes the book had but i can understand why sahara would have turned into something like the pink panther and lost its edge. Enders game is a movie released back in late 20, but that movie was based on a. It seems insulting to describe fifty shades of grey simply as a book.
There are many times that we read a book and our children dont even know there is a movie version. But i have to say, this one gave me a run for my money. If you read the book, you have an image in your head of what the. Using the handout as a guide, ask students, independently or in small groups, to discuss the changes they like most and least as well as the aspects of the film that remained true to the text that were most satisfying. In the case of a play versus its movie version, how did the film change the. But when i watched the movie, i realized that he is the most down to. In some ways, the movie is fabulous too, though not as graphic in some depictions of events as those in the book. Overall, if im pitting the book versus the movie, id choose the book. Mar 11, 2018 sahara feels more like a 1940s serial than a book written in 1991 or a movie made in 2005. Words are, of course, the most powerful drug used by mankind. What is a motif, and how can i find them in macbeth. And of course, movies bring the book to life, making you feel like youre actually part of the action.
This list includes books appropriate for grades 35 that have been made into movies. Book vs movie replay the color purple the alice walker pulitzerprize winning novel vs the steven spielberg multiacademy award nominated film the margos finally take on the classic which won both the pulitzer prize for fiction and the national book award in 1983. November marks the release of several movies based on young adult novels, which makes it the perfect time for this kind of study. Once students have read the book, they can watch the movie. It had been a good six years since i had read the corresponding book, but i still remembered it somewhat. With matthew mcconaughey, penelope cruz, steve zahn, jude akuwudike. When i finally heard that in fact a movie, based on the book sahara, was finally in production, i nearly died and went to heaven. Something that i have never said when comparing a novel to a film, is that the pacing. Now, amidst the blazing, shifting sands of the sahara, dirk pitt will make a. However, movies takes at most 4 hours of your time, such as the movie lord of the rings 3, but the average length of a movie is between 1. Timothy has a real person as company called phillip. If youre more of a visual person, movies will stay with you more than words on a page. The characters are too thin, the violence too careless, the suspension of disbelief required too strenuous, the treatment of nonwhites too stereotyped. Laurence gives beth a piano because she reminds him of his deceased little.
Watching a movie after reading the book is a wonderful way to encourage students to think critically about how each medium presented roughly the same information. Jan 14, 2015 first blood is best known as the first rambo movie. Crusaders attorneys claim the movie lost more than. Ways that the book and movie are different include characters. After all, he was supposed to be so intelligent and wise. It stars matthew mcconaughey, steve zahn and penelope cruz and is an international coproduction between the united kingdom, spain, germany and the united states. Even though the movie did a great job making the book come to life, the movie and book had a couple differences. Free use these two printables after you have read the book and then seen the movie version. Movie and book comparison essay examples essay example.
After reading into the wild, i decided to watch the movie and compare and contrast. Get an answer for what are the differences between the baseball movie the natural and the book the natural by bernard malamud. Without a doubt, sahara is one of the best books i have ever read. The english patient is luminous on the page and on the screen in a rare case, michael ondaatjes book stands in its unique splendour while anthony. Review of clive cusslers high adventure treasure hunt novel by two book.
Lee in 1865, the confederate navy ship css texas is being loaded at a dock with crates supposedly filled with documents. Due to a lawsuit the 2005 film sahara is one of the few hollywood flops with open books. If you continue browsing the site, you agree to the use of cookies on this website. Ways that the book and movie are the same include setting. Great for comparing and contrasting and thinking critically about how the movie was made. With this organization, you would first write about the strengths and weakness of the book, and then about the movie. One last thing that the book and movie had in common was that each time mitch went to visit morrie he could tell morrie was getting worse and worse. If i were trying to place it within a genre and compare it within that genre, i would place it. And movies based on books can spark interest in the book its based on, making people want to read the book. Did the setting in the movie look like you had imagined it. Lovable, roistering, tequilaswigging treasurehunter dirk pitt is in the african desert. Movie column we are going to look at and compare a popular book and its film adaptation. Jan 08, 2015 the movie also lost a bit of that tongueincheek comedy with the action scenes the book had but i can understand why sahara would have turned into something like the pink panther and lost its edge id recommend this if you enjoy action adventure stories think indiana jones and the temple of doom, think goonies shout out to.
Ways that the book and movie are the same include characters. Automatic weapons are fired in virtually every other scene, with dirk and al often serving as targets for a mali militia. The plot begins with a confederate ironclad, the texas, outrunning a union blockade while carrying on board not only the souths treasury but also the norths kidnapped president. Comparing a book and film version of a story tes resources. Encourage students to take notes on similarities and differences they notice, such as the fact that in matilda, by roald dahl, the little girl protagonist, plays three tricks on her parents in the book, but in the movie, she only plays two tricks. Toward the heart of the sahara, chic but lost in its. Then, in 1931, worldfamed aviatrix kitty mannock an amelia earhart clone vanishes on a flight over the sahara, her plane or body never seen again.